Warm afternoon light falls across a landscaped courtyard with empty café tables outside a quiet Southern California shopping arcade.

The Village at Orange Is Being Rebuilt From the Edges In

The middle of the Village at Orange is gone. The enclosed mall closed on January 31, 2024, and its interior came down in early 2025. Demolition of the former JCPenney building came after. Along the outer edge on N. Tustin Street, the center still runs a full day. Walmart opens at 6 a.m. and closes at 11 p.m. Trader Joe's has more room than it used to, and a conveyor-belt sushi restaurant opened this year where none existed before.

The city released its draft plan for the 60-acre property in October. It puts nearly all of the change on the edges and leaves the working stores alone, which tells you a lot about the next several years on this stretch of Tustin Street.

What came down, and what was left standing

Each step of the teardown reached a different part of the site, so the order matters:

  1. 2009: Sprouts Farmers Market opens in July. Next to the Trader Joe's, it moves the center toward groceries and everyday errands.
  2. 2017: TRC Retail buys the mall property from Vestar.
  3. 2020: Integral Communities buys the former JCPenney portion.
  4. January 31, 2024: The enclosed mall closes and most of the interior empties, while exterior anchors including Walmart stay open.
  5. 2024: Saunders Properties buys the old Sears portion, and TransformCo, the Sears company, keeps its long-term lease.
  6. Early 2025: About 158,000 square feet of interior mall space is torn down, and the JCPenney building follows.

Sears closed long before the mall did. In 2021 the Orange County Register reported the closing of what it called Orange County's last traditional Sears, and a 2025 city staff report lists Sears among the closed anchors. The lease still runs. That one fact shapes more of the site's future than anything else in this post.

The ring that kept working

The stores that survived were the errand stores, and the new tenants have joined them. Here's who's on the property:

  • Walmart #2546, 2300 N. Tustin St., open daily 6 a.m. to 11 p.m.
  • Trader Joe's, 2114 N. Tustin St. The city lists its expansion in 2025. The Register reported that the plan turned the shuttered CVS next door into the new sales floor and kept the original space for inventory and storage.
  • Sprouts Farmers Market, the center's other grocery anchor.
  • Ulta, which moved in 2025 from the old interior mall into the former Party City space on the same property.
  • Kura Revolving Sushi Bar, 1500 E. Village Way, Suite 2203. The Register reported it was set to open in March 2026, and Kura's Orange page now lists daily hours, pickup and delivery.
  • Sourdough & Co., next door at Suite 2204. Its location page lists daily hours and online ordering.
  • Mr. Moto Pizza, 2202 N. Tustin St., Suite C, which its location page lists as now open.
  • CAVA, 2318 N. Tustin St., with dine-in, pickup and delivery.
  • Rounds Korean BBQ, which the city lists among the leases signed in 2025 and 2026.

Most of that list was signed after the mall closed. The city's property history names Rounds Korean BBQ, Sourdough & Co., Kura and Mr. Moto as leases signed in 2025 and 2026, all of them on the outer edge along Tustin Street and Village Way. None of them waited for a master plan.

The draft plan builds on the same edges

The city began the Meats to Heim Specific Plan in January 2026. It covers the mall site from Heim Avenue on the north to Meats Avenue on the south, between Canal Street and Tustin Street. The owners are paying for it. A July 2025 city staff report puts the total for consultant work and city staff time at $1,430,028.19, funded by the Village at Orange ownership group.

City Manager Jarad Hildebrand and the consulting firm PlaceWorks presented the draft preferred plan on October 15 at St. Paul's Lutheran Church to about 200 people, according to the Foothills Sentry. The draft splits the property into 12 planning areas and allows up to 834 homes by right.

Where those homes can go matters more than the total. Under the draft, homes can be built only along the Canal Street side on the west and the Meats Avenue side on the south. The first row facing Canal is capped at two stories, rising to three on the interior, and the mixed-use "neighborhood hub" areas top out at four stories. Four small open spaces add up to 2.44 acres, ranging from a half-acre public park to a paseo and a plaza. The Tustin Street side, where the stores are, stays commercial.

The city's Meats to Heim project page says there is "no plan to remove the occupied retail on the site".

Two phases, a generation apart

Under the draft, the site changes in two stages, and the gap between them is longer than most mortgages people are paying off today:

Phase 1 Phase 2
Homes 333 Up to 444
New commercial space 72,000 sq ft 163,000 sq ft, mixed use
Timing Anticipated by 2030 After 2054
What holds it back Plan adoption and later project approvals The TransformCo lease on the Sears parcel

The Sears building has been closed for years. Its lease is the reason the largest share of new commercial space in the draft can't happen for roughly three more decades. The road change waits too. The draft would realign Canal Street to meet Lincoln Street instead of dead-ending at Meats, and that work is scheduled for Phase 2, after 2054.

The Sears parcel also explains why a Costco isn't in the draft. The Foothills Sentry reported that the draft has no Costco option on the Sears property because Costco needs at least 18 acres for a warehouse and gas station. On the same project page, the city says it "is not preventing Costco or any specific retailer from being located on this site," and that tenant choices belong to the property owners.

Walmart is the one existing store the draft could change. The draft allows a substantial addition to the store, which would likely mean tearing down the current building and replacing it with a supercenter. If Walmart doesn't expand, the land behind it could take 90 homes. Both are draft options. Neither is a commitment.

The calendar from here

The deadline for written comments on the draft is November 13. Here's what comes next, according to the Foothills Sentry and the city's project page:

  • Final preferred plan, followed by a Draft Environmental Impact Report, with a public scoping meeting to set what the EIR studies.
  • Public comment on the EIR, which the city says includes formal review periods and responses to comments before adoption.
  • Orange Planning Commission, then the Orange City Council, with review expected in summer or fall 2027.
  • Separate approvals for each project. The city's project page says the specific plan "does not approve construction," and any future building needs its own applications and approvals.

The former JCPenney land has its own history. In May 2025 the Orange County Business Journal reported a proposal for 167 condominiums there. The city says that application is paused, no action has been taken, and no new development has been approved anywhere on the property. The city has tried to plan this corridor before. Its broader North Tustin Street Specific Plan, which ran from Katella Avenue to Lincoln Avenue, was canceled by the City Council in August 2022.

The earliest a council vote can happen is mid-2027, the first new homes are anticipated by 2030, and the Sears parcel stays as it is until after 2054. Until then, the Village at Orange is Walmart, Trader Joe's, Sprouts, Ulta and a growing group of restaurants along Tustin Street and Village Way, which is the same center Orange shops at this week.

Changes at a property this size affect the streets around it, from Canal to Meats to Heim. If you own a home nearby and want to know how the Meats to Heim timeline could affect what it's worth, Tina Tan Group can walk you through the draft and what has sold nearby. Request Your Home Valuation.

Work With Tina

What sets Tina apart is her genuine passion for helping others, coupled with her extensive network of vendors ready to assist with any need. When you choose Tina Tan as your real estate partner, you not only gain a dedicated agent but also access to a wealth of resources tailored to your journey.

Follow Me on Instagram